ALL TIME ALL-CITY QUARTERBACKS
NOTE: Prior to 1965 only eleven player offensive teams selected for All City.
| year | last name | first | pos | ht | wt | class | paper | note |
| 1995 | Neighbors | Kareem | QB | 5-11 | 172 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1994 | Cuprisin | Andy | QB | Sr. | Courier | Honorable Mention | ||
| 1993 | Cuprisin | Andy | QB | Jr. | Courier | Honorable Mention | ||
| 1989 | Huebner | Brian | QB | 6-1 | 155 | Jr. | Press | |
| 1980 | Erwin | Todd | QB | 6-0 | 165 | Jr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 1977 | King | John | QB | Sr. | Courier | Special Mention | ||
| 1975 | Herr | Dennis | QB | 6-1 | 170 | Sr. | Courier & Press | QB-Courier QB&DB-Press |
| 1974 | Schmidt | Jim | QB | 6-1 | 175 | Sr. | Courier & Press | DB-Courier QB-Press Honorable Mention |
| 1963 | Volkman | Dean | QB | 6-0 | 175 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers + All SIAC Courier MVP |
| 1961 | Martin | Mickey | QB | 5-8 | 180 | Sr. | Courier | Honorable Mention |
| 1960 | Volkman | Mike | QB | 6-0 | 175 | Sr. | Press | Honorable Mention |
| 1958 | Buck | Bill | QB | 5-9 | 162 | Sr. | Courier | Honorable Mention |